Article Sections
DSL Broadband: The Limits
Basic performance of perfect copper pair Cat3 cable.
(Neglecting Cross talk)
Line distance roughly converts to attenuation (and vice versa)
These are for perfect lines and ZERO crosstalk.
Older eircom DSL enabled exchanges are DSL with eircom and ADSL2+ if LLU. Recently enabled eircom exchanges are mostly ADSL2+ even without LLU, eircom or other companies' Bitstream.
Green line is newer eircom ADSL2+ exchanges (or some Smart or Magnet or BT).
Blue Line is original eircom ADSL exchanges and original bitstream.
Red line looks something like T1 (original Broadband).
In practice there is not much advantage to ADSL2+ more than 3km (45dB to 50dB) or to VDSL more than 1km from the exchange.
A model showing effect of crosstalk.
ADSL2+ and 1000's of feet (Km are approx 1/3)
Those nearer exchange more likely to have higher crosstalk (more pairs in cable)
See also Kitz about DSL stats
Another model for km rather than dB attenuation
The average is about 3km, which typically is a lot less than 10Mbps
The Average line length is slightly under 3km in Ireland and only 15% are more than 6km (too long). However pairgains or poor line or bad connections can make a line fail. A multipair cable only 500m can be half as fast as the graph if there are a lot of DSL customers which increases cross talk. Increasing Interleaving (higher latency) reduces crosstalk and helps maintain a higher speed. ADSL2+ has slightly less crosstalk issue than original ADSL.
Also http://www.internode.on.net/residential/broadband/adsl/extreme/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G.DMT
This good too
http://www.dslreports.com/forum/remark,12770014
10Mbps with DSL2+ corresponds to about 3km or AVERAGE line length, i.e. About 1/2 of customers can't get 10Mbps even if every line is perfect and has ADSL2+. At 3km VDSL is no help. In the real world maybe 40% of lines could do 10MBps or more even if EVERY line is working and has ADSL2+
To even have > 3Mbps on DSL for 80% of people is probably impossible. At the very least you ned HFC/Coax or FTTC + VDSL/ADSL2+ in Urban/Suburban (10Mbps via longer ADSL2+ from fibre fed cabinets for sparcer Suburban).
Fixed Wireless can easily deliver 5Mbps (20km) to 10Mbps (15km) to the rest of rural too far from cabinets. Some Rural would get cabinet (FTTC) + ADSL2+ at 5Mbps to 10Mbps.
This is why the LLU argument and Bitstream pricing and Line Rental issues are becoming Moot. We need NOW a new plan with FTTC, Cable, FTTH/FTTK and quality Fixed Wireless. The existing eircom infrastructure can't provide.
YouTube "so callled" HD is near 2Mbps. If you have more than one user in an Home/Office/Digs then 8Mbps down/1Mbps up is a minimum. 5Mbps is an absolute isolated one user rural minimum.
Some confirmation of figures, read between the lines using above info
http://archives.tcm.ie/businesspost/2007/11/04/story27834.asp
Eircom to expand broadband speeds four-fold
Sunday, November 04, 2007 - By Adrian Weckler
Eircom plans to upgrade up to a third of its broadband lines to facilitate speeds of 25 megabits per second (Mbs) - more than four times the speed of its current highest home service - by 2010, according to its chief technology officer.Geoff Shakespeare said that 37 exchanges - representing almost 600,000 working phone lines - have been earmarked for the upgrade.
He also said that, in the next three years, more than half of all the company's phone lines are planned to be upgraded to facilitate speeds of 12Mbs. The upgrades represent a €60 million investment in the company's “core network'‘, according to Shakespeare.
He said towns with at least 2,000 working lines will be prioritised for the build-out and that the services will have “no contention ratio'‘, meaning speeds will not vary depending on how many others are on the line at the same time.
“It's being driven by decentralisation, demands by enterprise and also competition from cable companies,†said Shakespeare.
However, until then, most users will only see “incremental'‘ speed increases of up to 6Mbs over the next two years, he said.
Shakespeare said that Eircom's investment in creating a ‘next generation network' will be based on both very high speed digital subscriber lines (VDSL) and ADSL 2 technology.
“Theoretically, VDSL can get you 100Mbs, but 25 is more realistic. We have 37 exchanges initially marked for VDSL and are waiting for the business case for enabling them to be signed off. ADSL 2 is ideally up to 24Mbs, but on our network you're looking at about 12Mbs.
“But that's just up to 1 kilometre from the exchange. After that, it begins to drop off. Putting VDSL into our cabinets and driving that from there is our plan.â€
Shakespeare said that eliminating the speed of contention and backhaul would boost users' broadband experience.
“In the current environment, up to 6Mbs is as much as our lines will take,†he said.
“The goal now is to take the contention out of the network and take backhaul out of the network. Our current average loop length is about 2.7 kilometres, but some are as long as eight to nine kilometres. The longer it is, the more speeds drops off the line in the current environment.â€
Shakespeare said faster speeds will enable Eircom to enter new markets, such as television. He said the company was about to launch a trial in Temple Bar showing TV and film content over broadband lines. This will be among a test audience of up to 100 people, he said.
The service will entail ‘on-demand' programmes and films, where users can pick programmes from any part of listed TV schedules and pause, fast-forward or rewind through the broadcast. Content could include films such as Die Hard 4.0, as well as hundreds of hours of BBC, ITV and RTE content.
Eircom is currently obtaining the temporary rights from TV stations' rights holders to switch the service on. The service is the first shot in Eircom's pursuit of becoming a ‘triple play’ operator, providing telephone, broadband and television over one phone line.
Shakespeare said that Eircom is following models used in other European countries.
“The proof is in Holland, Belgium, France and Britain,†he said. “At a certain point, exchange-based copper will become uncompetitive.â€
Shakespeare said that Eircom will also provide a new home-fibre broadband service - with a speed of 24Mbs - to 100 apartments in Sandyford, most of which are social housing units. He said that the trial will be free for a year for the residents.
“Whereas before we took the view that broadband was purely demand led, we're now taking a punt on broadband in the future,†he said.
As of January 2009 they have done little of this, but note that on the average approx. 3km line the VDSL does not give 25Mbps, but only marginally more than ADSL2+, about 7Mbps at best, very little advantage for 1km and none really for 8km. More than 5km you need a repeater 1/2 way (Like BT's "DSL REACH" scheme).
